From the ashes, hope rises

It was difficult to explain to my colleagues yesterday why the fire at Notre Dame cathedral in Paris was so devastating. There is simply no equivalent in the United States of a building that has such a rich historical, spiritual, artistic, and even geographical significance to an entire nation.

Eiffel Notre Dame 1060200 CC BLOG

In both a literal and a figurative sense, Notre Dame cathedral represents the heart of Paris — and of France.

Kilometer zero 1220165 BLOGKilometer zéro, from which all distances in France are measured.

It has been a touchstone for millions of people in moments of both grief and joy.

It also has been one of the few constants across centuries of human history: For more than 850 years it has survived invasions, plagues, revolutions, and floods.

Notre Dame 1090592 CL BLOG

Notre Dame 1230724 cnew BLOG

Notre Dame and Seine 1410006 IB BLOG

Notre Dame back 1250430 CX 2 BLOG


Notre Dame in snow 1180117 CL2 BLOG

Notre Dame sunrise 1080855 reworked CR CX2 BLOG

So it felt inconceivable yesterday to watch the flames engulf the roof and see the spire collapse into the glowing furnace where only two hours before a priest had been holding mass. I kept thinking it was a nightmare, except that I couldn’t wake up.

NOtre Dame spire 1220431 BLOG

Notre Dame incense 1360373 BLOG

This morning there were glimmers of hope that at least the bones of the ancient structure might be saved.

And the bell towers survived — along with the enormous bourdon Emmanuel, which dates to 1686 and was the only bell at Notre Dame to escape the French Revolution. (Already this morning its Wikipedia entry had been updated: “It was not affected by the fire of April 15, 2019.”)

The new bells that were installed in 2013 seem to be okay as well.

Notre Dame bells 1040507 BLOG

But so many other questions remain: What of the stained-glass rose windows? One Twitter account says they “exploded.” (Probably untrue.) Another says the upper halves melted. (Sadly, more plausible.)

Notre Dame rose 1260028 BLOG

Notre Dame rose 1010398 BLOG

Notre Dame 1120006 CL BLOG

Notre Dame rose 1010402 BLOG

Notre Dame rose 1010406 BLOG

And what about the enormous paintings and frescoes in the chapels that surround the ambulatory — and the sculptures, and the priceless hand-carved wood panels?

Notre Dame chapel 1010360 BLOG

Virgen de Guadalupe 1290023 BLOG

Notre Dame chapel 1240231 BLOG

Notre Dame herself 1110909 lighter BLOG

We’ll have to be patient in the coming days for more answers to emerge. But for now my profound admiration and gratitude go out to the 400-plus firefighters whose skill and courage prevented a total loss.

Even if only its shell remains, I will return to Notre Dame again and again during my next visit, as I have always …

Notre Dame en lumiere 1120289 BLOG

Notre Dame balloons 1100165 CL CR BLOG

Notre Dame moody 1070471 CX BLOG

Notre Dame murmuration 1190129 CX CL BLOG

Notre Dame and moon 1250489 CC CL BLOG

… because you don’t have to be Catholic or even French to appreciate the beauty and significance of this monument to hope.

Notre Dame monks 1360990 BLOG

Notre Dame nuns 1360436 BLOG

“Notre Dame is our history, our literature, part of our psyche, the place of all our great events, our epidemics, our wars, our liberations, the epicentre of our lives … so I solemnly say tonight: We will rebuild it together.” — President Emmanuel Macron

Notre Dame diorama 1010384 BLOG

This diorama exhibit inside the cathedral (above) demonstrated how it was built more than 850 years ago. 

Notre Dame model 1360449 BLOG

Notre Dame ringer 1100323 CX LT BLOG

Update • Posted April 17, 2019: The immense 13th-century rose windows, the Great Organ, and much of Notre Dame’s art have weathered the historic fire. And the rooster  — a symbol of France — that fell with the spire has also been found among the rubble. My grief has turned into hope that Our Lady will rise once again from the ashes.

Text and all images © Heather Munro.